Are you suffering from knee pain, and are you finding that hyaluronic acid injections are no longer providing the desired effect?
Hyaluronic acid is an excellent ingredient that not only acts as a lubricant for joints but also soothes inflammation and protects cartilage. Since it is a component that is naturally present in joints, many people will find it easy to choose as a way to treat knee pain.
However, even if you feel the effects at first, it's not uncommon for those effects to diminish over time. Many people may feel anxious, wondering, "Should I continue with the injections?" or "Are there any other options?"
This article explains the causes and solutions for when the effects of hyaluronic acid injections diminish. We will also provide specific information on when to reconsider your hyaluronic acid approach and what the next steps should be, so please use this as a reference.
table of contents
Reasons why hyaluronic acid injections stop working
Hyaluronic acid injections are a widely used treatment to alleviate knee pain caused by conditions such as osteoarthritis. However, it is common to see cases where the effects diminish over time or with repeated injections. Let's take a closer look at some of the reasons for this.
Progression of osteoarthritis of the knee
As the condition of the joints deteriorates over time, the stress on the bones and soft tissues due to deformation becomes greater, which can lead to the inflammatory symptoms described below, and hyaluronic acid alone may not be effective.
Worsening of inflammation
Research has shown that hyaluronic acid not only acts as a lubricant for joints, but also possesses anti-inflammatory properties. This is because it plays a role in suppressing the activity of cells that cause inflammation. However, if the inflammation within the joint becomes too severe, the effect of hyaluronic acid may be relatively weakened.
The more severe the inflammation, the more difficult it becomes to manage the pain with hyaluronic acid alone.
Weight gain
As your weight increases, the strain on your knees increases, and they may become relatively weaker compared to when you were lighter.
Increased activity level
Excessive exercise or work can change the strain on your knees, which may make it harder to feel the effects.
Will antibodies against hyaluronic acid be produced?
Besides the above, there is also the theory that, "Just as the effectiveness of a drug diminishes with prolonged use, tolerance to hyaluronic acid may develop."
However, hyaluronic acid is a naturally occurring component found in all parts of the human body, including skin, eyes, and joints, and is completely different from a drug. Furthermore, there is no clear evidence to support the claim that "tolerance develops with long-term use of hyaluronic acid."
It would be more natural to assume that your knee is in a worsening condition, or that it is being subjected to excessive strain.
When to reconsider hyaluronic acid injections
If you stop feeling the effects, you may start to experience the following symptoms:
Pain recurrence
Previously, hyaluronic acid injections would alleviate the pain, but now I feel like they don't reduce the pain as much, or perhaps they have almost no effect at all.
Decreased motor function
Hyaluronic acid injections no longer seem to have a positive effect on my walking distance or endurance. I'm experiencing difficulties with daily activities, such as walking shorter distances and having trouble going up and down stairs.
The duration of the effect becomes shorter.
"Previously, one injection would provide relief for a month, but now the pain returns within a week."
If you experience these symptoms, the effects of hyaluronic acid injections may be diminishing. While there are various factors involved, such as the function of the joint itself, muscle strength, and activity level, it's best to consider these as signs that your knee condition is worsening.
Of course, the decision of whether or not to continue hyaluronic acid treatment rests with the doctor, so it's not something you can decide on your own. However, you should definitely tell your doctor if you feel that "the effects are becoming less noticeable" or "you're wondering whether or not to continue hyaluronic acid injections."
Injecting into a joint inherently carries certain risks, such as infection. Continuing injections when the pain is barely reduced may provide temporary relief, but it's not a truly effective solution.
Based on a comprehensive assessment of the actual condition of the knee joint, the degree of pain improvement, and the patient's complaints, they should be able to suggest additional treatments, a change in approach, or even surgical intervention.
Other
The following treatments are either performed in parallel with continued hyaluronic acid treatment, or they are performed after discontinuing hyaluronic acid treatment.
Drug therapy
Treatment involves using painkillers and anti-inflammatory drugs.
You may be prescribed oral or topical nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), or pain relievers tailored to the severity of your pain.
Steroid injection
In cases of severe inflammation, steroid injections may be administered to provide a short-term relief.
Because it has a stronger anti-inflammatory effect than hyaluronic acid, it often provides immediate relief even in cases of severe pain.
However, it's important to keep in mind that, like hyaluronic acid injections, it cannot be done frequently and does not provide a fundamental solution.
Rehabilitation
Even if hospitalization is not required, it may be possible to receive outpatient rehabilitation while visiting the hospital.
In institutions that provide outpatient rehabilitation, rehabilitation may be chosen as one of the approaches.
We aim to reduce pain by strengthening the muscles around the knee and improving joint mobility, as well as by using physical therapy (heat and cold therapy and electrical stimulation).
Surgery (total knee joint replacement)
If the knee joint is in poor condition and the above approaches are ineffective in improving motor function or reducing pain, surgery may be recommended.
Depending on the condition, there are various surgical methods such as osteotomy, but in most cases, total knee replacement surgery will be chosen.
When an artificial knee joint is implanted through surgery, the narrowed space in the knee and the bony protrusions (osteophytes) are replaced with artificial bone, resulting in a properly functioning knee joint.
The disadvantages include the need for hospitalization due to the surgery, and the requirement to endure pain from the surgery for a certain period. Since rehabilitation must also be continued, this treatment method may not be suitable for those who cannot easily be hospitalized due to work or family commitments.
This option is also unavailable if surgery is not possible due to pre-existing medical conditions or other factors.
A new treatment method: "regenerative medicine"
Regenerative medicine is an innovative treatment method that utilizes the body's natural repair capabilities to repair and regenerate damaged tissue. In recent years, it has also attracted attention as a new treatment for knee problems.
If hyaluronic acid injections are no longer as effective, but you don't want to just wait for your knee to get worse, and you don't want surgery, then regenerative medicine is one option worth considering.
PRP (platelet rich plasma) therapy
This procedure involves injecting plasma containing concentrated platelets extracted from blood and growth factors. It helps repair damaged areas and reduces knee pain and inflammation.
Stem cell therapy
We use "stem cells" extracted from adipose tissue and bone marrow to promote the regeneration of cartilage and ligaments.
Regenerative medicine utilizes the body's natural repair mechanisms by using the patient's own blood and tissues. Because it uses components derived from the patient's own body, the risk of allergic reactions and other complications is significantly reduced. Another major advantage is that it allows for knee joint treatment without hospitalization or surgery.
Stem cell therapy, in particular, has the effect of regenerating cartilage and ligaments, so it can be considered a fundamental treatment for knee problems that can be chosen as an alternative to surgery.
summary
Each of these alternative treatments has its own advantages and disadvantages. It is important to consult with a specialist to determine the best option for you.
Furthermore, new treatment methods are constantly being researched and developed. To maintain knee health, let's broaden our range of knee care by staying up-to-date with the latest information.